A list of members banned from the Ray Peat Forum

It's due to Charlie's authoritarianism. Mephisto was taunting Charlie with: "just ban me already you prick". Of course, though Charlie most likely did want to ban him, this itch was overridden by his desire to not take orders from anyone.

A similar thing happened when Impero gave him the following ultimatum:

"So, which is it?

Are you taking the True Man of Honor and Integrity Way? (Posting your secret screenshot)

Or the easy way out? (Dropping the hammer)"

To which he replied "both", overriding not only his isolated desire to simply ban Impero, but also his previous decision to not share more proof. He couldn’t simply ban impero because that would have meant yielding power to Impero's ultimatum. In order to avoid this, he had to additionally go against his own word and show proof despite previously saying that he won't do it.

I think this suggests that Charlie cares more about power than personal integrity.

Update: I am now banned too as a result of this post.

deliciousfruit

Got banned for saying this:
I wasn't even trolling, I've been taking 15mg of copper daily for months and have only seen benefits.

I guess having an experience antithetical to the forum owner's narrative is a bannable offense now.

deliciousfruit

TheSir

@deliciousfruit said in A list of members banned from the Ray Peat Forum:

I wasn't even trolling, I've been taking 15mg of copper daily for months and have only seen benefits.

Hmm, so much for allowing respectful disagreements.

Peatful

https://raypeatforum.com/community/threads/the-low-toxin-lifestyle-is-about-removing-all-toxic-things-in-your-life-including-people.52707/

If anyone chooses to go back

I would love to know any reasons why

Mine would only be get my private messages of folks I was helping
And
See what bookmarks I had

Edit: oh. And no. Im not going back.

S.Holmes

"It is a paradox that every dictator has climbed to power on the ladder of free speech. Immediately on attaining power each dictator has suppressed all free speech except his own."

Barghest

@TheSir well mephisto, who is definitely not me, is banned now too because of your comment, seems like your analysis was perfect. I was not banned this morning before you posted that!

TheSir

@Barghest Ha, my apologies. It does seem like banning you was an attempt to invalidate the analysis. Yet by banning you just to invalidate the analysis, he inadvertently affirmed its conclusion: that he will always choose the action that is least damaging to his sense of power and control. In other words, he couldn't stand the accuracy of the analysis so he attacked it using the exact method the analysis highlighted.

ilovethesea

iPeat got banned in the “Mr Mercola” incident
https://twitter.com/ContrarianCorey/status/1735100745597218909

VehmicJuryman

Weren't all of you paying to use the forum? Surely he can't legally ban all of you, especially for simple disagreements or posts on other forums. Seems dangerously close to theft or fraud.

ilovethesea

@VehmicJuryman No anyone who was there before he started charging was grandfathered in.

Gaston

@TheSir It's a testament to your eloquence and tact that you were able to last so long. I had been enjoying reading your subtle jabs at Charlie. Congratulations on being banned.

Sweet Meat

@Amazoniac

did he ban anyone paying subscriptions?

Amazoniac

@saturnuscv said in A list of members banned from the Ray Peat Forum:

User “feedandseed” was banned in the original haidut ban thread

Melissa would've jumped in to intervene if she wasn't busy legitimizing Jorge's attacker. Her superpowers are brought up when convenient, but soon defaults to filing her nails while accepting the sportive disposal of members.

@TheSir said in A list of members banned from the Ray Peat Forum:

I am now banned too as a result of this post.

I've stumbled upon some of your questionings, they were precise and exemplary. It's a loss for them.

@deliciousfruit said in A list of members banned from the Ray Peat Forum:

Got banned for saying this:
I wasn't even trolling, I've been taking 15mg of copper daily for months and have only seen benefits.

I guess having an experience antithetical to the forum owner's narrative is a bannable offense now.

It's a little risky, but shows the concern that they have for members: you're taking something that they regard as harmful and you're dumped to continue to do it elsewhere.

@Sweet-Meat said in A list of members banned from the Ray Peat Forum:

@Amazoniac

did he ban anyone paying subscriptions?

Yes. What hasn't been banned yet?

@Sweet-Meat said in A list of members banned from the Ray Peat Forum:

@Amazoniac

did he ban anyone paying subscriptions?

He banned me. Twice. I joined in 2015 but like a fool I paid the subscription fee because I thought it was a good cause in the memory of Ray Peat. Pretty stupid of me.