Is higher metabolism good for longetivity?
-
@Isaac I cant find the exact quote but it was on danny roddy's generative energy podcast. I remember him talking about the misconception that low heart rate is good foe longevity because of the idea we only have a "certain ammount of breaths." So slowing the body's processes would theoretically extend lifespan in this ideology
-
@yerrag said in Is higher metabolism good for longetivity?:
@Ecstatic_Hamster said in Is higher metabolism good for longetivity?:
Conclusions: The TSH population shifts to higher concentrations with age appear to be a continuum that extends even to people with exceptional longevity.The inverse correlation between TSH and FT4 in our populations suggests that changes in negative feedback may contribute to exceptional longevity.
I'm not buying this. I consider the basis the medical system uses to determine the state of the thyroid all flawed, bases on Peat's views.
Here, they make the conclusion that the higher the TSH, the longer lived a person is, which you are well aware to not be in keeping with Peat's views on it.
It doesn’t say what you’re saying. It just says that testing people who are very old their TSH tends to be higher than people that die earlier.
-
there are a number of similar studies that show higher TSH correlates with extreme old age.
I think that there may be more at play. Old people have low thyroid activity and lower metabolic rate. Perhaps the ones with higher TSH who are very old have lower stress hormones. Dr. Peat said that stress hormones can lower TSH. There is evidence that this is wrong. I'm interested in investigating this.
-
@foobarbaazquux
Your experience and conclusions line up very much with Peat's. As far as exercise goes, Ray is on the extreme end of not doing much exercise but he certainly had a lot of internal metabolism to keep himself trim, and his research and writing that occupied his time uses a lot of cerebral activity which also uses a lot of energy.
I have not been heavy on the workout scene ever since but until about 12 years ago, I kept myself fit on an old progressive resistance program developed and commissioned by the RCAF (Royal Canadian Air Force) in the 60s called the 5BX for men and the XBX for women. It's no longer popular but it had served me very well as even after 12 years of intentionally slacking off the muscle tone has not disappeared. These days, I don't exercise much a la Ray Peat but my internal metabolism keeps me trim without having to engage in new fads such as Intermittent Fasting.
You're spot on when it comes to the benefits of strength training against the wear and tear from endurance training.
-
@Ecstatic_Hamster You're right.
Can I take this to mean that as we get older, our TSH tends to increase as a marker of health deterioration that comes with age?
-
@Ecstatic_Hamster said in Is higher metabolism good for longetivity?:
there are a number of similar studies that show higher TSH correlates with extreme old age.
I think that there may be more at play. Old people have low thyroid activity and lower metabolic rate. Perhaps the ones with higher TSH who are very old have lower stress hormones. Dr. Peat said that stress hormones can lower TSH. There is evidence that this is wrong. I'm interested in investigating this.
I remember differently on TSH. I recall Peat saying TSH as a stress hormone, and that the lower it is the better.
-
@yerrag said in Is higher metabolism good for longetivity?:
@Ecstatic_Hamster said in Is higher metabolism good for longetivity?:
there are a number of similar studies that show higher TSH correlates with extreme old age.
I think that there may be more at play. Old people have low thyroid activity and lower metabolic rate. Perhaps the ones with higher TSH who are very old have lower stress hormones. Dr. Peat said that stress hormones can lower TSH. There is evidence that this is wrong. I'm interested in investigating this.
I remember differently on TSH. I recall Pest saying TSH as a stress hormone, and that the lower it is the better.
yes I recall him saying that too. He may have been wrong?
-
@Ecstatic_Hamster I think he's right. As he views TSH as the lower the better, consistent with the idea that the less stressful conditions, the less the need for stress hormones such that zero be ideal.
He has talked if calcitriol, the active vitamin D hormone being one. Others -
PTH
Cortisol
Adrenaline (though I'm not certain)
Estrogen (though I don't think zero is good)Though he hasn't said so, my personal take is that insulin is a stress hormone as well.
-
@yerrag said in Is higher metabolism good for longetivity?:
@Ecstatic_Hamster I think he's right. As he views TSH as the lower the better, consistent with the idea that the less stressful conditions, the less the need for stress hormones such that zero be ideal.
He has talked if calcitriol, the active vitamin D hormone being one. Others -
PTH
Cortisol
Adrenaline (though I'm not certain)
Estrogen (though I don't think zero is good)Though he hasn't said so, my personal take is that insulin is a stress hormone as well.
Yes, but if he’s right about that, then why are people who are exceptionally long lived having higher TSH levels? Again I want to emphasize that this one study I cited is just one of several.
Peat was similarly absolute when it comes to estrogen as you know. And yet we have always found that we don’t feel well if estrogen is too low. Everything is a balance and it makes sense that that balance changes as we get older in order to compensate for aging processes.
-
It seems to me that the study only says that people get to have higher TSH levels as they get older. This is not the same as saying people having higher TSH levels get to live longer.
-
@yerrag said in Is higher metabolism good for longetivity?:
It seems to me that the study only says that people get to have higher TSH levels as they get older. This is not the same as saying people having higher TSH levels get to live longer.
Agreed.
