New "Mission" of RPF
-
@ThinPicking said in New "Mission" of RPF:
Yea... what the hell.
These people are in the green poo cult lmao. Notice how none of these people report "feeling good." Wasn't that like one of the issues he had with bioenergetics? Few people ever reporting success stories. Although I must say the ambiguity around the word success here troubles me.
Success of what? When someone says "Greetings, I have now achieved superior health and the optimal human form." then you know you're dealing with a nutjob, lol. Health can be hard to reclaim, even harder to maintain, and its something we all end up losing towards the end.
I remember he had some bullshit assessment that people should be living to 120, and if they don't, then you shouldn't be taking advice from them. Yeah, well, not only will Garrett or Charlie not live to be 120, I have my doubts that they'll ever see their 80s.
Linus Pauling, while far from perfect, would mega dose vitamin A daily and he lived to be like 93, lol. And I don't even think people should be mega dosing vitamin A, just making a point with regards to how stupid this toxin thing is.
-
@Mulloch94 yeah they seemed to define success on the peat diet based on weight loss, and complained there is no pictures to prove success, not everyone is targeting the same issues. How do I take a picture of my mental health and autism related issues improving lmao. Improvements will look different for everone, for me gaining weight was an improvement because I came to peat as an anorexic, addressing the delusional thoughts and OCD typical of anorexia seems like a success to me, considering plenty never recover or continue to relapse repeatedly. Some people may be severely disabled so improvement won't be six pack abs, it will just be getting out of bed or having the mental energy to face daily life. But no green poop means we have all failed.
-
@yerrag said in New "Mission" of RPF:
@Creuset said in New "Mission" of RPF:
@yerrag said in New "Mission" of RPF:
Are you saying this because you trust everyone and you leave your house doors and car doors unlocked? Either you live in the boondocks or you are too smart for your own good.
You seem to be assuming too many stuff and on defense mode man, relax, I was not talking about you but about Tara.
I will make it clearer since you didn't understand: Tara used to be a wise member, but when the covid craze hit, she got into full paranoia mode, probably because she is a nurse and everybody around her got afraid. Fear can be very contagious, and make smart people act stupid, especially for women who are usually more easily scared than men. I still remember perfectly when this pandemic hit, everyone around me was freaking out and completely irrational, so I'm not surprised at all that she would act this way.
Not saying that your hypothesis about her or Charlie are necessarily wrong by the way, even though I don't think the likelihood of this happening is high.
Sorry for taking your words out of context. I couldn't see thru the forest here, thanks for clarifying. You make a good point about Tara. Being in the trenches would be traumatic, and her perception could have been affected greatly.
It's still hard to think she could be so rattled. My impression of here was that of someone who has a moderating demeanor, and not one to easily be influenced by noise around her. She was nice to be around, like a fixture at RPF.
No offense taken, thank you for your respectful reply.
I know what you mean about Tara, I was also very surprised by how she reacted. However I've observed intelligent and wise people snap under specific circumstances already, so wouldn't be surprised if that's what happened to her.
-
@abhi said in New "Mission" of RPF:
@C-Mex Nope, its still like that
And someone mentioned "Lifegivingstore" so i tried access it and got exactly same message as with RPF 
Welp!So if I understand correctly, people here reporting still being blocked are all from Russian IP addresses? I do find this interesting from a political angle as they are still trying to perpetuate various versions of the Russian hoax (accuse of 'disinformation', etc.) here in the US. I'm sure it's just another coincidence...
I wouldn't worry about reading the mess that the RPF has become today, but i understand your concern for older content. Luckily some people have made backups -- I do hope they'll be offering access freely and easily in the generous spirit of Ray Peat.
-
@C-Mex Yes, totally agree with you
-
@Barghest Yeah, it kinda goes back to something I started noticing several years ago. A significant majority of forum users in health spheres are there because they already don't feel well. On average, health forums don't attract healthy people because healthy people have no interest. They attract sick people trying to become healthy. And when there is no unified theory as to what health is, except for the possible vague term "lack of sickness," no two people are going to be after the same thing.
Also, fat people will probably hate me for saying this, but losing weight is actually one of the more easier things to do. Correcting chronic aliments is what's hard. If all someone needs to do is lose weight then cut the fucking calories. If you can't do that on your own, then hire a personal trainer and set up a meal plan and exercise plan. There's plenty of people in bioenergetics that can help someone do that. Hans being a perfect example.
-
@Mulloch94 yeah you can lose weight following literally any diet, you don't need Ray or paelo or vegan, Ray was focused on different issues, not weight loss and bodybuilding
-
-
@Luke
TPTB find this strategy the most effective. -
Good insights. And congratulations on your success!!
-
@C-Mex said in New "Mission" of RPF:
Is there any truth to the rumour that his house was broken into and papers ruffled before he was interviewed by the guys filming On the Back of a Tiger? Then the film was never actually completed, just the raw footage released
Yes that’s from me. The filmmakers reached out to people who had donated when they were travelling around filming, I think this was around 2015? So I met up with them when they were in my city and they told me this directly in person. Apparently these break ins happened to Ray periodically over the years. That was why they filmed the footage at some Air BnB not his house. I also recall them telling me that at first he was extremely reluctant to participate. He probably only did so after learning how much the community had donated to make it happen.
In retrospect we all should have given the money directly to him. Another comment I remember was them telling me they were shocked he was poor.
They also told me even back then that RPF was being watched. Think that may have come from Georgi.
-
@Barghest this exactly. I’ve gained some weight peating. I also feel substantially less autistic, anxious, and neurotic.
Peating isn’t and was never about losing weight. The only people who are likely going to lose weight peating are people who are severely estrogen/cortisol dominant and overweight for that reason.
If someone’s whole idea of “health” is “I am lean” then I can definitely see peating being a disappointment.
Peating for me has mirrored the progress I made on my autism in my late teens with LSD, but rather than being cured all at once semi-temporarily, it’s been incremental permanent improvements over a long period of time. IMO, anything that moves me in this liberating direction mentally is objectively good.
But yeah, I’ve gained like 20 lbs… must be from my liver not working due to vitamin A toxicity. Better become a neurotic gaunt skeleton…
-
@ilovethesea said in New "Mission" of RPF:
@C-Mex said in New "Mission" of RPF:
Is there any truth to the rumour that his house was broken into and papers ruffled before he was interviewed by the guys filming On the Back of a Tiger? Then the film was never actually completed, just the raw footage released
Yes that’s from me. The filmmakers reached out to people who had donated when they were travelling around filming, I think this was around 2015? So I met up with them when they were in my city and they told me this directly in person. Apparently these break ins happened to Ray periodically over the years. That was why they filmed the footage at some Air BnB not his house. I also recall them telling me that at first he was extremely reluctant to participate. He probably only did so after learning how much the community had donated to make it happen.
In retrospect we all should have given the money directly to him. Another comment I remember was them telling me they were shocked he was poor.
They also told me even back then that RPF was being watched. Think that may have come from Georgi.
This makes me sad beyond belief, but I believe he chose to live simply and that is how he could do his work with integrity and not be beholden to anyone. I think he had/has a house in a general area near the University as he walked by me on the street once when I was visiting Eugene on a road trip many years ago. He walked briskly by toward an area with nightlife and outdoor cafes at around sunset and looked as if he was going somewhere. He said a quick hello as I did a double take but I was shell-shocked enough to not react except to look over my shoulder and watch him go.
-
Wanted to drop in and say hello to some old names and mentors. I was mostly a lurker but also a voracious reader and wanted to let all of you know that you guys and gals are great.
The contributions made sharing info, self experimentation, and especially help offered won't be forgotten.
We'll carry Ray's torch forward within the greater bioenergetic movement no matter what forum or group we find ourselves in. Hat tip
-
@saturnuscv yeah, I had six-pack abs you could ricochet bullets off of when I was over-training. But I also had insomnia, had to get up to pee frequently at night, stammered through conversations and barely spoke up. Often tongue-tied and looked down when people talked to me.
Now, I am sometimes amazed at my improved lingual skills. I'm sortof glib even. Assertively witty.
I sleep like the dead.
I only took LSD twice. It gave me temporary freedom from those symptoms too.
-
@C-Mex I was sad hearing that too, but I believe you are right it was by choice. I recall someone telling me they sent him money and he never even cashed the checks. Makes it all the more infuriating to see a dirtbag grifter like Smith smearing Ray’s name and Charlie propping him up into god-like status.
@yerrag interesting theory that Charlie was replaced. I remember you saying that about Tara during Covid and I agree her stance was weird as hell for a supposed longtime Ray Peat follower. If RPF was indeed being “watched” (as the filmmakers told me) then it only makes sense they would have “plants”. As for Charlie, I was there since 2013 and I remember he was always a bit authoritarian but not religious. Maybe they replaced him at some point with this new “end times” persona he has now? It definitely makes a mockery of everything Ray was about.
@jwayne I noticed Georgi started putting some of his product descriptions on the Idea Labs website instead of linking through to the RPF posts. So he may be doing an Irish exit from the forum.
@Regina I would love to hear more about your diet. You look incredible. It seems like the “new RPF” crew is prioritizing thinness (and green poop???) above all other health markers. I’d rather be a bit fat than have sallow skin, frown lines, veiny arms and grey hair. At least in her before picture she had nice pink skin and a rosy glow.
Anyone know what is the green poop they are supposedly “detoxing”? Could Charlie as the forum owner get in trouble for encouraging this? In light of Blossom’s photos it looks and sounds like they are all making themselves sick.
-
@ilovethesea I believe Mike Fave explained the bile colored poop in his very thorough deconstruction of the Toxic A pseudoscience. It isn't a healthy detox by any means. I'll see if I can find it again.
-
https://raypeatforum.com/community/threads/the-real-vax-reason-cast-your-vote.41787/
13.2% of Ray Peat forum MEMBERS (ones which can vote on a poll) thought the vaxx was to help people.
Shockingly oddIve worked in hospitals for many years.
It is an alternate universe.
Dogma
Indoctrination
Greed
Pride
Laziness
Bitching like you wouldn’t believe
Just so nastyIf Tara was in such an environment
Single mom of a son iirc
She was probably in survival modeCognitive dissonance
-
@S-Holmes said in New "Mission" of RPF:
@ilovethesea I believe Mike Fave explained the bile colored poop in his very thorough deconstruction of the Toxic A pseudoscience. It isn't a healthy detox by any means. I'll see if I can find it again.
Here it is. Begin at 12:15
https://youtu.be/twZHuy5EoqA?si=n7WqoScaiw2jX-sH -
@S-Holmes Thank you. Interesting comments from this person under Mike’s video...
@will_of_europa
1 day ago
I'm one of the top researchers under Garret and Grant's camp.
I don't know who Charlie is, only that he's forcing low A down Peat forum's throats.
I do find this odd. As much as I can back all of my claims up with papers, I'm not entirely sure why Charlie has operated in the way that he has. Low A has a lot of enemies as the moment, so I wouldn't rule out the possibility of enemy agents trying to ruin our optics.@will_of_europa
1 day ago (edited)
I'd like to know too. I don't know anybody in the Low A Toxic Bile Theory movement who's actually spoken to Charlie, and I'm one of the leading researchers. Seems odd, and not how I would go about introducing new ideas to somebody else's legacy.@will_of_europa
1 day ago
As far as I know Garret hasn't even talked to Charlie, or any of us doing TBT theory for that matter. We don't know who he is.
