@DavidPS
I've thought along the same lines but struggled to fit those concepts coherently together.
expression of Hmgcs2, the gene encoding rate-limiting enzyme of ketogenesis, decreases significantly in Leydig cells from aged mice. Additionally, the concentrations of ketone bodies β-hydroxybutyric acid and acetoacetic acid in young testes are substantially higher than that in serum, but significantly diminish in aged testes. Silencing of Hmgcs2 in young Leydig cells drives cell senescence and accelerated testicular aging.
So what I'll do is shower you and the others with my open questions:
First in line for me is the question: Why is (testicular) Hmgcs2 being downregulated in aging?
Obviously feeding BHB as the end product of ketogenesis increased testosterone. Therefore the underlying mechanism can't be about sex hormone substrate availability (cholesterol). Rather, it's about a decline in ketogenesis, i.e. a tissue energy depletion: "suppression of ketogenesis impairs steroidogenic function of LCs"
Is it locally or systemically/predominantly hepatically?
--> The study tells us it's locally, because testicular tissue concentrations are higher than serum and "BHB andAcAc concentrations in serum were comparable between the young
and the aged group (Fig. 2k, l)."
"Remarkably, the concentration of ketone bodies in the testes were more than tenfold higher than that in serum (Fig. 2i–l), implying ketone bodies might have testis-specific functions"
Is there a decline in peripheral fatty acid circulation as a reason for declining tissue ketogenesis?
In contrast to ketone bodies, free fatty acids don't really cross the blood--brain-barrier. Do they significantly cross the blood-testis-barrier?
If it's not about fatty acids as a ketogenesis substrate, is it about peripheral protein circulation levels?
If it's about neither upstream substrates, is there perhaps a tissue-specific decrease of utilization to Acetyl-CoA? Is the HMGGCS2-decreasing cause founded in a lack of carnitine or a lack of CoA?
Will supplementation of carnitine or stimulation of CoA then attain similar results to exogenously supplying BHB for that matter?
--> The authors have followed this strain of thought and injected AAV vectors to deliver and overexpress the Hmgcs2 gene, demonstrating "that Hmgcs2 overexpression increased the levels of H3K9ac and FOXO3a in aged testicular tissue, similar to the levels in young testes"
--> So it's not immediately about any substrate levels but HMGCS2 activity itself.
Does this lead back to epigenetic downregulation of bodily functions, in this case HMGCS2, and the concepts of DNMTi and HDACi?
--> Clearly there's a positive association between acetylation of H3K9 and HMGSC2 expression in rats in that HMGSC2 induced higher H3K9ac.
Is this reciprocal, i.e. would H3K9ac also induce HMGCS2?
Or does H3K9ac come about by increased concentrations of the products of HMGCS2, like BHB, and the cellular energy abundance provided by it?
--> The authors followed this and found: "Consistent with in vitro results, Western blot analysis revealed that BHB increased the levels of H3K9ac and FOXO3a in aged testicular tissue, similar to the levels observed in young testes (Fig. 7d, e)."
Is this then a course of gradual decline, wherein a decrease of testicular ketone energy in turn decreases its own synthesis? Just as the observation that more BHB increases its own synthesis? I.e. a positive / negative feedback loop?
Would, therefore, a one time course of exogenous BHB or induced Hmgcs2 overexpression "reset" testicular ketogenesis back to a youthful level, wherefrom it may once again gradually decline?
--> Well, the authors fed exogenous BHB in addition to the control diet to 18-months old rats for a duration of 2 months. Those were then 20-months old rats. Unfortunately, no subgroup to follow up on wrt to their physical activity and testicular findings has been kept and reported on beyond that.
"Last, we validated the changes in FOXO3a-related inflammation genes through quantitative RT-PCR analysis, revealing that inflammation-related genes were significantly upregulated in aged mice, and Hmgcs2 overexpression reduced the expression of these genes (Supplementary Fig. 9b–e).
Overall, these data suggest that enhancing ketogenesis is sufficient to alleviate LCs senescence and testicular aging in aged mice."